Skip to main content

Design-build vs design-bid-build for commercial projects

How design-build and design-bid-build differ, the trade-offs for commercial and institutional owners, and the Florida public-entity rules that may apply.

By AV Construction Group Corp. Published 6 min read

Illustration for articles about general contracting

In design-bid-build, an owner hires a designer first, finishes the drawings, and then bids construction to contractors. In design-build, the owner signs one contract with a single team that handles both design and construction. Design-build can shorten schedules and put responsibility with one party, while design-bid-build gives the owner more direct control over the design and a price based on completed documents. Neither is best for every project, and public owners in Florida must follow specific procurement rules.

What each method means

Design-bid-build is the traditional sequence. The owner has separate contracts with an architect or engineer and with a builder. Design is completed, the project is bid, and the builder is usually chosen on the lowest qualified bid for a fixed price based on detailed drawings and specifications.

Design-build uses one contract for design and construction, with a team that may be led by a contractor or by a design firm. Design and construction overlap, and the owner often selects the team on price, proposed solution, qualifications, or a mix.

A third model, construction manager at risk, sits between them: the owner hires a designer separately, and a construction manager joins during design, then takes on construction risk, often with a guaranteed maximum price. The AIA and AGC primer describing these methods does not endorse any one as best.

Trade-offs for owners

Time

Design-build allows work to overlap and avoids a second procurement round after design. A 2006 Federal Highway Administration study of mostly highway projects, with a small matched sample of 11 pairs, found design-build was associated with shorter schedules, but the procurement step itself took longer. Highway projects differ from buildings, so treat those findings as indicative, not as a forecast for your project.

Cost

The same study found no clear net cost advantage in design-build overall, and in its matched pairs the design-build projects showed more cost growth. It did find lower owner administration and inspection costs and fewer claims. Bid-based pricing in design-bid-build gives a market price against complete documents, but changes found during construction can still raise cost.

Control and design quality

With design-bid-build, the owner's designer is separate from the builder, so the owner keeps direct control of the design and a built-in check on construction quality. Construction decisions must be made early, and the process is less flexible. With design-build, the owner gets one point of responsibility, but roles must be defined carefully, and some decisions come after construction starts. The FHWA report noted agencies were less experienced with design-build, which can affect the owner's ability to evaluate proposals.

Risk

Lump-sum design-build contracts shift much of the risk of completing the project to the design-builder. Owners should still decide what they want in writing before selection: performance criteria, quality standards, and what counts as an owner-requested change. A clear written owner's program gives both sides something to measure the design against.

When owners tend to choose each

  • Design-bid-build suits projects with well-defined scope, an owner who wants a competitive price on finished drawings, and a schedule that can absorb sequential phases.
  • Design-build suits projects where schedule certainty and single-point responsibility matter, or where contractor input on constructability and systems is useful early.

Florida rules for public entities

Private owners can choose freely. Public owners in Florida cannot. Always confirm with the entity's procurement office or counsel, since rules differ by entity type and change over time.

Design-build under s. 287.055

Section 287.055 is Florida's professional-services selection law. It generally does not govern an agency's design-build procurement; agencies follow their own procurement laws, rules, and ordinances, and the Department of Management Services sets rules for state agencies. For municipalities, political subdivisions, school districts, and school boards, the statute allows either a competitive proposal process or a qualifications-based process that leads to negotiating a guaranteed maximum price and completion date.

If a competitive proposal process is used, it must at minimum:

  • Have a design criteria package prepared.
  • Select at least three most-qualified design-build firms.
  • Set weighted evaluation criteria covering price, technical, and design aspects.
  • Evaluate proposals against those criteria.

The design criteria professional who prepared the package cannot provide services under the resulting design-build contract. A design-build firm, as defined in the statute, is either certified to contract through a certified or registered general or building contractor as its qualifying agent, or qualified to practice engineering, architecture, or landscape architecture.

Local competitive bidding under s. 255.20

For local governmental entities, construction estimated above $300,000 must be competitively awarded to a properly licensed contractor, with a lower threshold of $75,000 for electrical work. Both amounts are indexed to the Engineering News-Record Building Cost Index. The statute accepts sealed bids, requests for proposals or qualifications, and competitive negotiation, and it expressly permits construction management and design-build arrangements. Price-based awards go to the lowest qualified and responsive bidder, and RFPs and RFQs must be publicly advertised. A qualified contractor that could have won competitively can sue to challenge a local government's compliance.

Construction management under s. 255.103

A governmental entity can also select a construction management entity through the s. 287.055 process. After selection, it can require a guaranteed maximum price or lump-sum price with a guaranteed completion date, in which case the entity must post a surety bond under s. 255.05. The statute also sets a $7.5 million per-project ceiling for continuing contracts, adjusted each July 1.

Other public buyers

Federal agencies and other public buyers follow additional rules that are outside the scope of this article. For an overview of public-sector work, see government contracting.

Questions people ask

Is design-build always faster?

Not always. The FHWA study found shorter project durations on average, but procurement took longer. Schedule benefit depends on how clearly the owner defines requirements and how well the team is managed.

Does design-build mean no competitive bidding?

No. Florida law describes competitive proposal and qualifications-based selection processes for public design-build, so competition still occurs; it is just based on proposals rather than finished drawings.

Who is responsible for design errors?

That is set by the contract. Ask counsel how design responsibility, warranties, and insurance are allocated in either model.

Check before you decide

  • Define your goals: schedule, budget certainty, design control, or flexibility.
  • Decide how complete your program and site information are before choosing a method.
  • For public work, confirm which statute and local ordinance govern your procurement.
  • Confirm that the design-build firm's license structure fits section 489.119 and the design-professional statutes.
  • Have counsel review contract forms, including change, warranty, and insurance terms.

For commercial scopes, see the overview of general contracting, and for owners planning a tenant space, commercial tenant improvement permits in Miami-Dade.

Sources

  1. AIA and AGC - A Primer on Project Delivery Terms
  2. FHWA - Design-Build Effectiveness Study (final report, 2006)
  3. Florida Statutes s. 287.055 - Acquisition of professional architectural, engineering, landscape architectural, or surveying and mapping services
  4. Florida Statutes s. 255.20 - Local bids and contracts for public construction works
  5. Florida Statutes s. 255.103 - Construction management entities
  6. Florida Statutes s. 489.119 - Business organizations; qualifying agents

Planning a project?

Tell AV Construction Group Corp. about your project and we will follow up.

Keep reading

More guides on the blog