Skip to main content

How to compare roofing proposals: a checklist

What a good roofing proposal should include: product line, layers, flashing and vents, permit, warranty, cleanup, change orders, license and insurance.

By AV Construction Group Corp. Published 4 min read

Illustration for articles about roofing

In short: two roofing proposals can look alike and describe very different roofs. Compare them line by line: the products, the layers under the shingles, the flashing and vents, the permit, the warranty, the cleanup, how changes are handled, and the contractor's license and insurance.

Why the total is not enough

It is tempting to look only at the last line of a proposal. But a roof is a system of parts, and each proposal may include different parts. One may replace the flashing and the vents. Another may reuse them. One may include the permit. Another may leave it to you.

This checklist does not talk about prices. It helps you see what each proposal actually includes, so you compare the same roof.

The checklist

Use these points with every proposal you receive. If a point is missing, ask for it in writing.

Product and line

A good proposal names the manufacturer and the product line of the shingles, not only "architectural shingles." It also names the color.

Ask whether the starter shingles and the hip and ridge shingles are from the same manufacturer. Owens Corning, for example, presents these as parts of its Total Protection Roofing System.

The layers under the shingles

The shingles are only the top layer. Under them, the proposal should name:

  • the underlayment that covers the roof deck;
  • the water barrier for the places where water is most likely to get in;
  • what happens if the roof deck is damaged: how it is checked and how repairs are handled.

Flashing and vents

Flashing is the metal that seals the joints: along walls, around chimneys and pipes, and at the edges. Vents let the attic breathe. The proposal should say whether the flashing and the vents are new or reused, and how the attic will be ventilated.

The permit

A roof replacement usually needs a permit. In Miami-Dade, residential roofing permits go through the county's permitting system. The proposal should say who applies for the permit, who schedules the inspections, and that you will receive a copy of both.

The warranty and its registration

The proposal should name the warranty that applies to your roof. Owens Corning, for example, offers a product warranty and roofing system warranties, and the system warranties need a set of its own parts. Ask:

  • which warranty applies, and which products it needs;
  • who registers the warranty, and when;
  • what the contractor's own terms for its work are, if any.

Get the warranty name in writing. When the work is done, ask for the product documents and the registration confirmation.

Cleanup

The proposal should describe how the old roof is removed and where it goes, how the yard and the driveway are protected, and how nails and debris are cleaned up at the end. If recycling the old shingles matters to you, ask about it here.

Change orders

Surprises happen on roofs. Once the old roof is off, the deck may need more work than expected. A good proposal explains how changes are handled before they happen:

  • who approves a change;
  • how it is written down;
  • that no extra work starts without your approval in writing.

Schedule and access

A proposal should also say how the job will run. Ask when the work can start and how bad weather is handled. Ask what the crew needs from you: access to the driveway, a place for the dumpster, cars moved and pets kept inside. Ask who your contact person is during the job, and how you will hear about a delay. Clear answers make the days of work easier for everyone.

License and insurance

Check the contractor, not only the proposal:

  • License: ask for the Florida license number and look it up on the state's license search. Check that the name matches the company on the proposal.
  • Insurance: ask for proof of insurance.

If the contractor says it is part of a manufacturer's network, look it up on the manufacturer's website.

Putting it together

Lay the proposals side by side and go down the list. Mark what each one includes and what is missing. Then ask each contractor to fill the gaps in writing. Only then compare the totals. Our article on how to compare contractor bids in Florida covers the same idea for other kinds of work.

Next step

Start with a preliminary estimate online, or request a visit. The final price is confirmed after a site visit, in a formal proposal. Read more on our Owens Corning page, and see our roofing services.

Sources

  1. Owens Corning - Roofing warranties (viewed 2026-11-04)
  2. Owens Corning - Total Protection Roofing System (viewed 2026-11-04)
  3. Miami-Dade County - Roofing e-permitting system guidelines (viewed 2026-11-04)
  4. Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation - License search (viewed 2026-11-04)

Planning a project?

Tell AV Construction Group Corp. about your project and we will follow up.

Owens Corning Preferred Contractor: what it means for your roof

AV Construction Group Corp. is an independent contractor. Owens Corning and its trademarks belong to Owens Corning.

Keep reading

More guides on the blog