Skip to main content

How to compare contractor bids in Florida

Compare Florida contractor estimates apples to apples: scope, line items, allowances, exclusions, payment schedule, license and insurance, and contract basics.

By AV Construction Group Corp. Published 7 min read

Illustration for articles about general contracting

To compare contractor bids fairly, put them side by side on the same scope of work, the same materials, the same exclusions, and the same payment terms. A low number often means something was left out, not that the work costs less. Before price, confirm each bidder holds the right Florida license and insurance, and that the draft contract says in writing what you are buying.

Start with a single scope

Bids are only comparable if each contractor priced the same job. Florida's Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) advises getting written estimates from several licensed contractors, each listing the work, the materials, the completion date, and the total cost. The state's Insurance Consumer Advocate guide goes further: itemized estimates from at least three licensed, insured contractors, and caution about estimates much higher or lower than the others or vague lump sums.

Practical steps:

  1. Write a one-page scope: rooms or areas, what is demolished, what is new, finishes, fixtures, and who is responsible for permits.
  2. Give every bidder the same drawings, photos, and list of selections.
  3. Ask each to submit in writing, and to note anything they assumed.
  4. If a bid differs, ask why before deciding it is better or worse.

Read the line items

An itemized bid lets you see where numbers differ. Look for:

  • Permit and inspection fees. Whether they are included and who applies.
  • Demolition and debris removal. Including dumpster and disposal.
  • Materials, by name. Brand, model, size, and grade, not just "tile" or "cabinets."
  • Labor and subcontracted trades. Electrical, plumbing, or mechanical work often requires a separately licensed trade.
  • Protection and cleanup. Floors, furniture, dust control.
  • Overhead and profit. Shown as a line or built into the prices; either is fine if it is clear.
  • Contingency. If one bid holds money for surprises and another does not, they are not equal.

Allowances: the biggest hidden difference

An allowance is a budget placeholder for items not yet selected, such as flooring, cabinets, or fixtures. One legal-marketplace guide explains that if your final choice costs more than the allowance, the difference is usually handled through a change order, and that underspending should be credited back. Allowances are a legitimate tool, but two bids can look the same while one assumes a basic tile and the other a premium one.

Ask for each allowance:

  • What exactly it covers (materials only, or installation too)
  • The dollar amount, and whether it reflects current pricing
  • The date by which you must choose, since late choices can delay the schedule
  • How overages and credits are documented

Exclusions and assumptions

Exclusions are the work a contractor did not price. Common ones include rotted wood or concealed damage found after opening walls, electrical panel upgrades, engineering or design fees, landscaping repair, and permit-related corrections. None of these is automatically unreasonable. What matters is that you see them in writing and can compare them.

Ask also how unforeseen conditions are handled: a written change order, signed before extra work, with the price stated.

Payment schedule and deposits

Compare the schedule as closely as the price. DBPR lists demanding most or all of the money up front, accepting only cash, or asking you to write checks to an individual as signs of an unlicensed contractor. The Insurance Consumer Advocate guide advises that advance payments should not exceed 50 percent of the full price, that you pay by check or card to create a record, and that final payment be made only after the work is complete to your satisfaction.

State law adds a check on large deposits. Under Section 489.126 of the Florida Statutes, if a contractor takes an initial payment of more than 10 percent of the contract price for residential repair or improvement, the contractor must apply for needed permits within 30 days and start work within 90 days after the permits issue, unless there is just cause or you agree otherwise in writing. This does not ban deposits; it sets deadlines. Ask an attorney how it applies to your contract.

A payment schedule tied to completed stages is easier to follow than dates on a calendar. Make sure the last payment is tied to final inspection, the final payment affidavit, and a completed punch list.

License, insurance, and who is on the bid

Verify before comparing. Ask for the license number and check it on the DBPR site. The guide above notes an occupational license or an LLC registration does not qualify someone to act as a contractor. For how to read the categories, see contractor license lookup in Florida and how to hire a licensed general contractor.

The Insurance Consumer Advocate guide advises verifying workers' compensation coverage or a valid exemption through the Department of Financial Services and requesting a certificate of general liability insurance. NRCA gives similar advice for roofing: ask for copies of liability and workers' compensation certificates and confirm they cover the whole job.

Also check who will do the work. A licensed contractor may use subcontractors, so ask which trades they will self-perform.

Contract basics under Florida law

This is a high-level overview, not legal advice. A lawyer can review your contract.

  • Written and complete. The state guide says the contract should be in writing with a full work description, start and estimated completion dates, an itemized budget, and a payment schedule, with no blank areas on a signed contract.
  • Recovery fund statement. Under Section 489.1425, residential contracts for work worth more than $2,500 must include a statement about the Florida Homeowners' Construction Recovery Fund.
  • Lien notice. Section 713.015 requires a bold, capitalized disclosure about construction liens in many direct contracts over $2,500 on residential property of up to four units. It must be signed and dated by the owner.
  • Unlicensed contractors. Under Section 489.128, a contract entered into by an unlicensed contractor is unenforceable by that contractor.
  • Final payment affidavit. Under Section 713.06, the contractor must give the owner a final payment affidavit when final payment is due. See construction liens in Florida.
  • Right to cancel. The Attorney General's office describes a three-business-day cancellation right for certain home solicitation sales, meaning sales made in your home or away from the seller's regular place of business. Whether it applies to your contract depends on the facts; ask.

A simple comparison grid

ItemWhat to compare across bids
ScopeDoes each bid match your written scope?
MaterialsNamed by brand, model, and grade?
AllowancesWhich items, and how much?
ExclusionsWhat was left out of each price?
PermitsIncluded, and who applies?
PaymentsDeposit size and stage-based schedule
DatesStart and completion dates in writing
CredentialsLicense and insurance verified?

Questions people ask

Is the lowest bid a red flag?

Not by itself, but DBPR warns about contractors who claim to be the fastest or cheapest. Find out what the low bid leaves out before comparing totals.

Should I ask for a lump sum or an itemized price?

Itemized, at least for your own review. The state guide lists a vague lump-sum estimate as a red flag.

Can I negotiate the payment schedule?

Yes. Ask for payments tied to completed work, and keep the final payment for after completion and the paperwork above.

Check before you decide

  • Each bid is based on the same written scope.
  • Allowances, exclusions, and change-order rules are in writing.
  • License, workers' compensation, and liability coverage are verified.
  • The deposit and payments follow a schedule you understand.
  • A lawyer has reviewed the contract if the job is large.
  • Laws change; confirm current requirements before signing.

For help scoping a project, see general contracting services.

Sources

  1. Florida DBPR: Tips for Hiring a Contractor (copy hosted by the City of Port St. Lucie)
  2. Florida Insurance Consumer Advocate: Don't Be a Victim, Prevent Contractor Fraud and Abuse
  3. Florida Statutes s. 489.126: Moneys received by contractors (2026)
  4. Florida Statutes s. 489.1425: Recovery fund statement in residential contracts (2025)
  5. Florida Statutes s. 713.015: Mandatory provisions in direct contracts (2025)
  6. Florida Statutes s. 713.06: Final payment affidavit (2025)
  7. Florida Statutes s. 489.128: Contracts by unlicensed contractors (2025)
  8. Florida Attorney General: The Cooling-Off Rule
  9. UpCounsel: Construction contract allowances
  10. NRCA: Selecting a roofing contractor

Planning a project?

Tell AV Construction Group Corp. about your project and we will follow up.

Keep reading

More guides on the blog