A critical path method (CPM) schedule is a project plan in which every activity is linked to the activities before and after it, so the longest chain of dependent work can be identified. That chain, the critical path, sets the earliest possible finish date. Public owners often require CPM schedules because they let the owner track progress, review pay requests, and judge time extension requests. Whether one is required on your job depends on the contract. This article is general information, not legal advice.
What a critical path schedule is
A CPM schedule starts with a list of activities, such as mobilize, excavate, install underground piping, pour slab, submit and approve shop drawings, and inspect. Each activity gets a duration, and activities are tied together by logic: this cannot start until that finishes. The software then calculates the longest path through the network.
The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) schedule guide describes the critical path as the path of longest duration through the sequence of activities, and says it determines the earliest completion date. It defines total float as the amount an activity can slip before the end date is affected. Activities on the critical path have the least total float. If a critical activity slips a day, the finish date slips a day unless something else is changed.
A bar chart can look similar, but it may not show these links. The federal FAR schedule clause, 52.236-15, refers to a progress chart showing the work sequence and target dates. Many agencies and owners require more detailed CPM schedules by specification. The Department of Defense's unified facilities guide specification for project schedules, for example, requires the Critical Path Method using the Precedence Diagram Method.
Why public owners require them
Public owners are spending public money and have to manage time, cost and many contractors at once. A CPM schedule gives them:
- A plan for sequencing. It shows the order of work and what must be finished before the next trade can start.
- A basis for payment. The federal guide specification says the schedule determines contract earnings and progress payments, and allows withholding when directed schedule revisions are not incorporated.
- A monitoring tool. Updated schedules show which activities are behind and whether the finish date is at risk.
- A way to evaluate delay. When a time extension is requested, the schedule is the starting point for judging whether the delay really affected the completion date.
The GAO guide, written for government program oversight, lists ten best practices for reliable schedules. They include capturing and sequencing all activities, establishing durations, confirming the critical path is valid, ensuring reasonable total float, updating the schedule using actual progress and logic, and maintaining a baseline schedule.
What an owner may ask for
Requirements vary by owner and project. As an illustration, not as a Florida standard, the federal guide specification UFGS 01 32 01.00 10 (August 2023, Change 1 dated 08/24) requires:
- A preliminary schedule within 15 calendar days after notice to proceed and an initial schedule within 42 calendar days
- Monthly updates at a minimum, with an update meeting and a narrative report
- No leads and no start-to-finish relationships, and limits on activity durations
- Float defined as belonging to the project, available to both parties
- Qualified scheduling personnel and specified software
The broader federal construction clause is shorter. Under FAR 52.236-15, the contractor prepares a practicable plan and progress chart, usually submitted within five days after work commences unless the contracting officer sets another period. If progress falls behind, the contractor must take corrective action at no added cost, and the contracting officer may require more shifts, overtime or equipment. If the contractor fails to submit the schedule on time, the contracting officer may withhold approval of progress payments.
For Miami-Dade, school district, municipal and state projects, the project specifications decide the format, update frequency, software and approval steps. Read the scheduling section of the bid documents before pricing. If a CPM schedule is required, price the scheduler's time and the updating effort.
Updates
A baseline schedule is the approved original plan. Updates then record actual starts and finishes, remaining durations and logic changes. Updates matter because delay analysis depends on them. A schedule that is not updated with actual progress is a weak record of what happened.
Good practice, consistent with the GAO guide's best practices, is to keep the baseline unchanged, document each logic change, and make sure that reported dates match daily reports and inspection records. The federal guide specification adds that percent complete and remaining duration be updated independently, that actual dates match quality control reports, and that artificial constraints that hide or create float be prohibited.
Time extensions and delay claims basics
A delay claim asks for more time, more money or both because something outside the contractor's control pushed the work. The basic questions are almost always the same:
- Was the delay excusable? Under FAR 52.249-10, delays arising from unforeseeable causes beyond the contractor's control and without its fault, such as acts of the government, fires, floods, strikes and unusually severe weather, may be excusable. Subcontractor or supplier delays can qualify if beyond their control and without their fault.
- Did the contractor give notice on time? Under 52.249-10, written notice of the causes of delay is due within 10 days from the beginning of the delay unless the contracting officer extends that period. Contract notice windows are often short and are enforced.
- Was the delay on the critical path? A delay to an activity with float may not delay completion. The federal guide specification says a time extension is granted only if the delay consumes all project float and pushes the project end date past the completion date.
- Is there compensation? A time extension is not automatically paid. Extended overhead and other costs depend on the contract and on who caused the delay.
The guide specification describes a prospective time impact analysis, which inserts the delay event into the last approved schedule to model the effect, and retrospective methods that look back at what happened. Which method applies depends on the contract. Weather claims often turn on whether the weather was unusual compared with normal conditions for the location and season, so keep weather records. Whether a particular South Florida rain event is excusable depends on the contract language.
Related: change orders often include time. See change orders in public construction for how they are documented and priced.
Questions people ask
Does every public project require a CPM schedule?
No. What is required depends on the owner and the contract. The federal FAR clause calls for a progress chart, while some specifications call for a full CPM network. Read the bid documents.
Who owns float?
It depends on the contract. The federal guide specification says float belongs to the project, but other contracts may say otherwise. Check the scheduling specification.
Can a late schedule affect payment?
On federal contracts under FAR 52.236-15, the contracting officer may withhold approval of progress payments if the schedule is not submitted on time. Check your contract for similar terms.
Do I need software?
Specifications often name the software or file format. Some federal specifications name Primavera P6. Check the bid documents before choosing a tool.
Check before you decide
- Find the scheduling section and any liquidated damages terms in the bid documents.
- Confirm required software, update frequency and who approves the schedule.
- Keep daily reports, photos and correspondence that match the schedule.
- Send written delay notices within the contract deadline.
- Ask a construction attorney or qualified scheduler before submitting a delay claim.
For the wider project delivery context, see design-build vs design-bid-build in Florida.
