Skip to main content

Tile, metal, shingle or flat roof in South Florida

Compare tile, metal, asphalt shingle and TPO or other flat roofing in South Florida: wind, heat, salt air, code fit and what to ask before you choose.

By AV Construction Group Corp. Published 6 min read

Illustration for articles about roofing

No roof type is best for every South Florida building. Metal had the lowest damage rate in one large post-hurricane survey, tile has improved but depends heavily on how it is attached, asphalt shingles showed the most damage in the same survey, and flat roofs rely on membrane attachment and edge details. In Miami-Dade, the right choice also has to carry a current Notice of Acceptance (NOA) and suit your roof's slope.

Slope comes first. Steep-slope roofs (2:12 or greater, per Miami-Dade's definition) can take shingle, tile or metal. Low-slope and flat roofs use membrane or built-up systems. Standing seam metal panels that pass a static water-leakage test may go as low as 1:12, according to the county's roofing code summary.

Wind performance

Wind is the main stress on a Miami-Dade roof. The Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS) surveyed roofs after Hurricane Ian (2022) in southwest Florida using aerial and street-level imagery of about 3,600 single-family homes. It found:

  • Asphalt shingles had the most damage, with about half showing some, similar to Hurricane Charley in 2004. Roofs more than 10 years old were especially vulnerable.
  • Tile did much better than in 2004. About 40 percent had some damage, and significant damage was rare except on roofs more than 20 years old.
  • Metal had damage rates around 12 percent, mostly from nearby structures failing, and held up well in winds below 130 mph.
  • Low-slope commercial roofs had damage above 50 percent, mostly flashing or coping failures.

Those findings come from one storm in one region, not Miami-Dade, and they describe averages, not any individual roof. Installation quality, age and maintenance matter on every type. IBHS has also reported that sealant strength is a key factor in how shingles resist wind.

Heat and energy

South Florida's sun heats the roof surface and the attic below it. The Florida Solar Energy Center tested seven identical unoccupied homes in Fort Myers in July 2000, each with a different roof. Compared with dark gray shingles, white reflective roofs (white metal and white tile) cut cooling energy by roughly 18 to 26 percent, while terra cotta tile and light shingles saved less (about 3 to 9 percent). The study is more than two decades old and measured specific products in one month, so treat it as evidence that color and reflectance matter, not as a forecast for your home.

For low-slope roofs on cooled buildings, the 2023 energy provisions summarized by Miami-Dade call for aged reflectance and emittance values or a solar reflectance index, which is why white or light membranes are common on flat roofs. Confirm the values for your project with your designer or building department.

Salt air and corrosion

Coastal air speeds up corrosion of metal parts. For metal roofing, that puts the focus on the panel coating, the fasteners and where dissimilar metals touch. Miami-Dade runs a Roofing Fastener Listing Program that requires fasteners and batten plates in approved roofing NOAs to pass corrosion testing for HVHZ use. Ask your contractor to name the fastener and its listing, and to confirm that edge metal and flashing materials match what the NOA requires.

Material by material

Concrete and clay tile

Tile is heavy and relies on its attachment (adhesive foam, mortar or mechanical fasteners) and on the underlayment beneath. Miami-Dade requires NOAs for tile systems, and tile underlayments are tested too. The county's inspection checklist for tile includes checks at the base sheet stage, at tile placement, and at final, and for adhesive or mortar-set tile a static uplift test. The county's e-permit rules also limit mechanically fastened tile by slope.

Metal panels

Metal panel roofs are installed per the NOA, which fixes the panel type, fastener pattern and design pressure table. In the county's system, you pick one design pressure table and cannot mix attachment methods from different tables. In the HVHZ, a fire-rated system is required, so the coil manufacturer's fire listing is part of the paperwork. Standing seam and exposed-fastener systems differ in how fasteners are exposed and maintained, so ask which one is in the bid.

Asphalt shingles

In the HVHZ, shingles must have an NOA and meet county fastening and underlayment rules, such as a minimum number of nails per shingle and cold-adhesive beds at eaves and rakes in the county's summary. The county's e-permit rules set a minimum slope of 2:12 for shingles and a maximum mean roof height for the online route. IBHS data suggests age and sealing matter a lot for shingle wind performance.

TPO and other flat roofing

Flat and low-slope roofs use membranes such as TPO, PVC, EPDM, modified bitumen or built-up roofing. Building America guidance says hurricane suction can fail mechanically attached membranes and recommends fully adhered membranes in high-wind zones, with strong perimeter details because uplift forces are greatest there. In Miami-Dade, low-slope roofs need NOA-listed assemblies, roof drainage designed to clear water within 48 hours of rain, and attention to flashing, which IBHS found was the failure point on most of the damaged low-slope roofs in its Ian survey.

Comparing the four at a glance

FactorTileMetalShingleTPO / flat
SlopeSteep slopesSteep slopes; some standing seam panels down to 1:12Steep slopes (2:12 or greater)Flat and low-slope roofs
Key wind issueTile attachment and underlaymentFasteners, panel attachmentSealant, nailing, ageMembrane attachment, edges, flashing
Salt air concernMetal flashings, fastenersCoatings, fasteners, dissimilar metalsMetal flashingsMetal edge, fasteners
Heat noteLight colors reflect moreWhite coated metal reflected most in the FSEC studyDark shingles absorbed the mostWhite membranes common
Miami-Dade paperworkTile, underlayment, adhesive NOAsMetal panel NOA, fire listingShingle and underlayment NOAsSystem NOA, fire listing

Lifespan figures are not given here because they vary by product, installation, maintenance and exposure. Ask for the manufacturer's warranty terms in writing and compare what each warranty covers.

Questions people ask

Which roof is best for a hurricane?

No roof is hurricane-proof. Surveys show metal and well-installed tile faring better on average than older shingle roofs, but the approved assembly, installation quality and roof age matter more than the label. The permit inspections exist to check this.

Can I switch from tile to shingles, or the reverse?

Often yes, but the structure, slope and HVHZ product limits matter. The deck, framing and slope have to suit the new system. Ask the contractor and building department.

Does a different roof type change my permit?

Yes. Miami-Dade has separate permit categories and inspections for shingle, tile, metal and low-slope roofs. See roof permit requirements in Miami-Dade.

Check before you decide

  • Confirm your roof's slope and the product's NOA limits.
  • Ask for the NOA number, fastener listing and fire listing.
  • Ask how the installer will handle flashing, edges and penetrations.
  • Compare warranty coverage, not just price.
  • Use the roof measurement tool to get an area to share with bidders.

For a general discussion of price drivers, see what drives roof replacement cost in Miami-Dade. Codes change; verify with your building department.

Sources

  1. IBHS - Building performance in SW Florida during Hurricane Ian, Part 1: roof cover assessment
  2. Florida Solar Energy Center - Comparative evaluation of roofing systems and residential cooling energy demand in Florida (FSEC-CR-1220-00)
  3. Building America Solution Center (PNNL) - Low-slope roofs
  4. Miami-Dade County - 2023 FBC roofing code changes (HVHZ)
  5. Miami-Dade County - Construction materials and product approval (NOA)
  6. Miami-Dade County - Roof inspection checklist
  7. IBHS - Asphalt shingle durability

Planning a project?

Tell AV Construction Group Corp. about your project and we will follow up.

Keep reading

More guides on the blog