Skip to main content

Hurricane shutters vs impact glass in South Florida

How hurricane shutters and impact-rated windows protect openings, what approvals and permits apply in Miami-Dade, and how to weigh upkeep and trade-offs.

By AV Construction Group Corp. Published 7 min read

Illustration for articles about general contracting

Hurricane shutters are separate coverings that you close over windows and doors before a storm. Impact-rated windows are glass units built to take debris hits and stay in the frame, so they protect around the clock without any action from you. Both can meet Miami-Dade requirements if the product has a current approval and is installed to it. The right choice depends on who will deploy the protection, how it will be maintained and which openings you are covering.

What each one does

Wind damage to a house often starts with a broken opening. Once a window or door fails, wind pressure builds inside the house and can push on the walls and roof from within. FLASH, a nonprofit focused on home safety, compares it to a balloon that gives way at its weakest point. Protecting openings is about keeping that first breach from happening.

Shutters

A shutter is a covering that takes the debris impact so the glass behind it does not. The Florida Division of Emergency Management's Hurricane Retrofit Guide notes that shutters mainly guard against debris and may not stop wind pressure from breaking a weak door or window. It also says they must be well sealed to the house, because even small gaps let pressure build behind them.

University of Florida extension material from 2005 describes the main types:

  • Roll-down: metal shutters in a box above the opening, ready-installed and sometimes motorized.
  • Accordion: metal panels that are pulled across and locked.
  • Awning and Bahama or Colonial styles: hinged or propped panels that can also shade the window.
  • Hurricane screen: reinforced fabric that is light and easy to store, but the publication says debris can still break glass that touches it.
  • Storm panels: steel or aluminum panels that are installed before each storm, which the publication describes as strong but often heavy and hard to store.

That publication is old, and products have changed, so use it for the categories rather than for current product details.

Impact-rated glass

Impact glass is laminated: a membrane sits between two layers of glass, so the glass may crack but stays in place. The Retrofit Guide notes that tempered glass alone is not impact-rated and that a real impact product has a label listing the standards it meets. FLASH adds that impact glass cannot simply be fitted into an older frame, because the product is tested as a complete window system with its frame and anchors.

Approvals and testing in Miami-Dade

Miami-Dade County is in the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone (HVHZ). The county says products that form the building envelope, including doors, shutters and windows, need an approval before they can be used there. That approval is a Notice of Acceptance (NOA). For the basics, see Florida product approval and the Miami-Dade NOA explained.

Impact products in the HVHZ are tested under TAS 201 (impact), TAS 202 (pressure) and TAS 203 (cyclic pressure). An Intertek presentation to the National Glass Association says glazed openings within 30 feet of grade need the large-missile test, which uses a 9-pound 2x4 fired at 50 feet per second, and openings above that need the small-missile test. Confirm with the building department which level applies to each opening on your house. Details on windows and doors are in impact windows and doors in Miami-Dade.

County product control examiners also check that approved shutters are properly marked. Look for the product's permanent marking and keep a copy of the full NOA with your permit records.

Permits

Shutters need their own permit application in Miami-Dade. The county's submittal checklist uses one category for removable panels and another for permanent shutters, and asks for:

  1. The permit application, including the total area of panels or shutters.
  2. Two copies of a plan showing the size and location of each opening and the building's mean roof height.
  3. Two copies of the NOA, marked to show which panel and connection method is used. A Florida Building Commission High-Velocity Hurricane Zone approval can be accepted in place of an NOA on this checklist.

The checklist also says that at least one first-floor window or door, not counting the garage, must remain usable as an exit when all storm protection is closed.

For accordion shutters and storm panels in unincorporated Miami-Dade, the county's e-permit guidelines (dated 2020) apply only to contractors and require an NOA, with Florida approvals not accepted for that route. Accordion shutter permits there are limited to residential use. The guidelines say that not following the NOA's restrictions and installation requirements causes failed inspections. Cities within the county run their own building departments, so check with yours first.

Trade-offs to weigh

Cost depends on openings, sizes, products and labor, so get written, itemized proposals and compare the same scope. This article makes no price claims.

QuestionShuttersImpact glass
Who has to act before a storm?Someone must close or install them, in timeNo one; protection is always in place
Upper floorsDeployment can be harder; FEMA notes equipment may be neededSame as any window
StoragePanels need space; fixed types do notNone
MaintenanceMoving parts, tracks, locks and fasteners exposed to salt airFrame, seals and hardware like any window
Glass behind itStandard glass can stay if the shutter is rated and sealedThe glass is the protection
WaterNot fully watertight; the Retrofit Guide says water got past roll-down shutters in Hurricane IkeDepends on the unit, installation and flashing
Permit and approvalNOA or approval for the shutter systemNOA or approval for the window or door

A few other points come up often:

  • Mixed approaches are common. A house may have impact windows on some sides and shutters elsewhere. Every opening still needs a rated solution.
  • Garage doors and sliding doors are openings too. See garage door wind ratings in Florida and the HVHZ.
  • Insurance. The Retrofit Guide says protecting all openings is generally needed for wind-mitigation credits. Policies and credits vary, so ask your insurer and agent what documentation they accept before you buy. Nothing here guarantees a discount.
  • Egress. Miami-Dade's own preparedness guidance reminds households that exits get harder once everything is covered.

Maintenance

Miami-Dade advises homeowners to inspect existing shutters to confirm they are in good working order. In practice that means operating them before hurricane season, not during a storm warning. FEMA's handbook recommends corrosion-resistant hardware near the coast, and says shutters must be anchored to the wall framing and should carry a label showing they are tested and code compliant.

Impact windows need ordinary window care: check seals, weep holes, locks and hardware, and watch for water stains at the frame. Follow the manufacturer's instructions for both types, since altering a tested product or its anchoring can undo its rating.

Questions people ask

Can I mix shutters and impact windows?

Yes, as long as each opening has a product approved for its location and installed per its approval. Keep the NOA for each product with your permit documents.

Is plywood acceptable?

Miami-Dade's preparedness page mentions 5/8-inch plywood as an emergency option, alongside county-approved shutters. For permanent protection that you want documented on a permit, ask the building department what it will accept.

Do shutters need a permit?

Miami-Dade requires a separate shutter permit application, as above. Confirm the current requirements with your building department, because cities inside the county run their own permitting and rules change.

Which code edition applies?

Miami-Dade says applications on or after December 31, 2026, must follow the Ninth Edition (2026) Florida Building Code. Ask your installer which edition your application falls under and whether the NOA fits.

Check before you decide

  • Ask for the NOA or approval number for every product and read its missile rating, pressure rating and expiration date.
  • Confirm who pulls the permit and who handles inspections.
  • Ask who will deploy the protection, how long it takes, and where panels would be stored.
  • Check that the installation matches the approval drawings, including anchors and spacing.
  • Ask your insurer what documentation it needs before you commit.

See general contracting for how a licensed contractor can help scope the work.

Sources

  1. Miami-Dade County: Storm Protection (Shutters) Submittal Checklist
  2. Miami-Dade County: e-Permitting Accordion Shutters and Storm Panels Guidelines
  3. Miami-Dade County: Construction Materials and Product Control Brochure
  4. Miami-Dade County: Prepare Windows and Doors
  5. University of Florida IFAS Extension: Install Window Shutters (ABE375, 2005)
  6. Florida Division of Emergency Management: Hurricane Retrofit Guide, Openings
  7. FLASH: How to Protect Your Home's Openings with Impact-Resistant Windows
  8. FEMA: Hurricane and Flood Mitigation Handbook for Public Facilities, Fact Sheet 3.2 (2022)
  9. Intertek / National Glass Association: Hurricane Standards, Testing and the Product Approval Process
  10. Miami-Dade County: Ninth Edition (2026) Florida Building Code Change Notice

Planning a project?

Tell AV Construction Group Corp. about your project and we will follow up.

Keep reading

More guides on the blog