Skip to main content

Impact-resistant shingles: Class 3 vs Class 4 explained

What the UL 2218 impact test measures, how Class 3 and Class 4 differ, which Owens Corning lines list each, and what to ask your insurer in writing.

By AV Construction Group Corp. Published 7 min read

Illustration for articles about roofing

An impact-resistant shingle is one that has been given a Class 1 to 4 rating in a laboratory test called UL 2218, where steel balls are dropped on a sample roof. Class 4 is the top class and uses the biggest ball. Class 3 is one step below. The rating says how a shingle did in that controlled test, and nothing more. It is not a guarantee against hail, and it says little about hurricane wind. This article explains the test, shows which Owens Corning lines list Class 3 and Class 4 according to the manufacturer's sheets (viewed 2026-11-04), and lists what to ask your insurer before paying extra for a class. AV Construction Group works with Owens Corning products, and the manufacturer is one of its material suppliers.

What UL 2218 actually tests

The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS), a building-safety research organization, describes UL 2218 as a steel ball drop test for prepared roof coverings. The ball sizes by class are:

ClassSteel ball diameter
Class 11.25 in
Class 21.50 in
Class 31.75 in
Class 42.00 in

IBHS says the balls are dropped from the height that gives them the same energy as a hailstone of the same size. Each spot is hit twice. A sample passes only when the back of the shingle shows no opening, meaning no tearing, fracturing, cracking or rupture. Crushed granules, dents or marks visible only on the top surface are not counted as failures.

That last point matters. A shingle can earn a class and still look dented or lose granules on top. The test is about whether the shingle is breached, not whether it looks new.

Class 3 versus Class 4

Class 4 means the shingle passed the test with the 2.00-inch ball, and Class 3 with the 1.75-inch ball. Both are laboratory results from a test sample installed in a set way. Neither tells you the size of the hailstones your roof will meet, or how many hits it can take.

Which line lists which class

The product sheets viewed on 2026-11-04 list the following for Owens Corning lines. Wind numbers come from the same sheets.

LineImpact class on the sheetStandards citedWind rating on the sheetNote from the sheet
Duration (architectural)Class 3UL 2218, FM 4473up to 160 mphMid-range line
Oakridge (architectural)Class 3UL 2218110 or 130 mphEconomy line
Duration FLEXClass 4UL 2218, FM 4473up to 160 mphContains SBS polymer
Duration STORMClass 4UL 2218, FM 4473up to 160 mphNo SBS polymer
Duration MAXClass 3Check the sheetCheck the sheetThicker, 4 bundles per square
Duration COOLClass 3Check the sheetCheck the sheetReflective granules
Supreme (three-tab)NoneNone60 mphTraditional line

SBS is a polymer added to asphalt to make it more flexible. The sheets use that difference to explain two Class 4 products. Miami-Dade's Notice of Acceptance 26-0331.12 describes STORM and FLEX as shingles with an integrated polymeric backing material for impact resistance. It does not state a UL class itself, so the class is the manufacturer's claim and should be backed by the test report.

FM 4473 is a separate test standard that some sheets name next to UL 2218. Ask which classification an insurer accepts, because they may not treat both the same way.

What the class does not guarantee

  • It is not a hurricane rating. Impact class answers a hail question. Wind, wind-driven rain and debris are separate questions, tested by other standards. See how to read a shingle spec sheet.
  • It is not a promise about a real storm. IBHS says standardized tests do not exactly replicate natural hailstone impacts. In its 2013 to 2014 tests of 22 shingle products bought from local vendors, none of the products passed more than Class 2 impacts without at least one double-hit location failing, including products labeled Class 4. That is an older, limited study, but it shows why a class is a comparison tool and not a guarantee.
  • It is not a warranty. Whether damage is covered depends on the manufacturer's warranty and your policy. Read the actual documents.
  • It is not a substitute for installation quality. The class applies to the shingle as tested. The deck, the underlayment and the nailing all affect the outcome.

Approval comes first in the HVHZ

In Miami-Dade and Broward, an impact class does not replace the product approval. The NOA above lists the Duration family, including STORM and FLEX, with conditions such as the 33-foot roof mean height limit and installation under RAS 115. Read Florida product approval and NOA explained to see how the numbers on an NOA connect to your permit.

What to ask your insurer, in writing

Insurers differ, and policies change at renewal. A phone call is not a record. Send a short written question, and keep the reply.

  1. Does my policy give any credit or require a specific impact class? If so, which one?
  2. Which standard do you accept, UL 2218, FM 4473 or both?
  3. Which documents do you accept as proof: the product label, the NOA, the manufacturer's data sheet, the invoice, the permit and final inspection?
  4. Does the answer apply to the whole roof, or only to certain slopes?
  5. Does the class affect how a hail claim is handled?

Also ask the contractor to put the product line, the class and the approval number in the contract, so the paperwork matches what is installed. See wind mitigation inspections for how the roof's features are recorded for insurance in Florida.

Questions people ask

Is Class 4 always worth it in South Florida?

It depends on your goals. Impact class answers a hail question, while wind, wind-driven rain and product approvals are separate questions, so first decide whether a hail class matters to you. A Class 4 line can still make sense if your insurer values it, but confirm that in writing first and compare it with the approved products for your address.

Can I add impact resistance to my existing roof?

Not as a coating or an add-on. The class belongs to a tested product, so it comes with a replacement. If the roof is only damaged in places, see the 25 percent rule article for how repairs and replacements are classified.

Does a Class 4 shingle need a different installation?

It follows the manufacturer's instructions and the approval for that product. Ask for both, and confirm they match the permit.

Who decides whether hail damaged my roof?

Your insurer's adjuster and, if you ask, an independent licensed roofer. See the post-hurricane roof checklist for how to document damage first.

Check before you decide

  • Ask for the exact product line, the class and the test standard behind it.
  • In Miami-Dade or Broward, get the NOA number and confirm it covers that line.
  • Get your insurer's answers about class and documents in writing.
  • Read the manufacturer warranty, including what it excludes.
  • Make sure the contract names the product and the approval.
  • Ask your roofing contractor how the deck and underlayment complete the system.

AV Construction Group works with Owens Corning products and counts the manufacturer among its material suppliers. If you would like a roof quoted with these materials, you can request a roofing estimate from AV, read about our roofing services or contact us.

The ratings above are the manufacturer's laboratory classifications, not a prediction of how any roof will behave in a storm. The figures come from published manufacturer data sheets, public approvals and the IBHS report. This article is general information, not engineering or insurance advice.

Sources

  1. Owens Corning - TruDefinition Duration shingles (product data, viewed 2026-11-04)
  2. Owens Corning - Oakridge shingles (product data, viewed 2026-11-04)
  3. Owens Corning - TruDefinition Duration FLEX shingles (product data, viewed 2026-11-04)
  4. Owens Corning - TruDefinition Duration STORM shingles (product data, viewed 2026-11-04)
  5. Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) - Relative Impact Resistance of Asphalt Shingles: Summary of UL 2218 Impact Tests (August 2014)
  6. Miami-Dade County Product Control - Notice of Acceptance 26-0331.12 (Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration, STORM and FLEX)

Planning a project?

Tell AV Construction Group Corp. about your project and we will follow up.

Keep reading

More guides on the blog