Skip to main content

Smart thermostats in humid Florida: what they do and don't

What smart and programmable thermostats can and cannot do in humid South Florida, plus heat pump and multi-stage compatibility and ENERGY STAR guidance.

By AV Construction Group Corp. Published 6 min read

Illustration for articles about HVAC

A smart or programmable thermostat controls when your system runs. It does not make the air conditioner larger, smarter at removing moisture, or more efficient by itself. In humid South Florida, the biggest wins come from sensible setpoints and a fan setting that suits your climate. Before you buy one, confirm it works with your exact equipment, especially a heat pump or a multi-stage system.

What a thermostat can and cannot do

A thermostat is a switch with a brain. It reads indoor temperature and tells the equipment to start, stop or change speed. Programmable models follow a schedule. Smart models add Wi-Fi, an app, and sometimes learning, occupancy or location features.

What it can do:

  • Raise the setpoint while no one is home and bring the house back before you return.
  • Give you remote control and run-time information.
  • Join utility programs, where offered. ENERGY STAR notes that some certified models work with utility incentive programs for grid reliability.

What it cannot do:

  • Fix an undersized, oversized or leaky system.
  • Add a second speed to single-speed equipment.
  • Remove moisture the equipment is not designed to remove.

ENERGY STAR says certified smart thermostats are independently certified using field data to deliver energy savings, but its page gives no percentage figure. It also notes that features vary by model and that remote features depend on an internet connection and the maker's app. Treat any savings promise on a box as a best case.

Why humidity changes the advice

Most thermostat advice comes from regions where the main goal is saving heat. South Florida is mostly the opposite. The air conditioner is also the dehumidifier, and it only removes moisture while it runs.

  • Large setbacks have a cost in humid weather. A DOE presentation on humid climates describes periods when there is little temperature load to trigger the thermostat while indoor humidity stays high. A deep daytime setup lets humidity rise, and the system then works hard to recover.
  • Fan setting matters. A federal building-science resource recommends the fan on central systems be set to Auto rather than On for efficient operation, and notes that moisture left on the cooling coil can return to the airstream. Continuous fan can re-add moisture between cooling cycles.
  • Oversized equipment short cycles. The same sources explain that an oversized unit cools quickly, shuts off, and leaves moisture behind. A thermostat cannot cure that. See AC sizing and efficiency in South Florida and controlling indoor humidity.

A practical approach is a moderate setback of a few degrees when away rather than a dramatic one, then watch indoor humidity. A hygrometer (a small humidity meter) shows what the thermostat display does not.

Heat pump and multi-stage compatibility

Equipment type decides which thermostat will work. Check these before buying.

Heat pumps

A heat pump uses a reversing valve to switch between cooling and heating. Carrier explains that a heat pump thermostat controls that valve through a dedicated O or B terminal and manages auxiliary heat, and that a standard thermostat lacks the logic to do this. It warns that an incompatible thermostat can cause malfunctions and damage the compressor. This applies even where heating is rarely used, because the same equipment handles cooling.

Auxiliary (backup) heat is the electric strip or furnace that supplements the heat pump. Large morning setbacks in heating mode can trigger it. One state energy office says programmable thermostats are generally not recommended for heat pumps in heating mode because deep setbacks can cancel savings, while raising the setpoint in cooling mode does save energy.

Multi-stage and variable-capacity equipment

A two-stage system runs at reduced capacity most of the time and at full capacity when needed. Carrier states that a two-stage thermostat only helps if the equipment itself has two stages. It also says a basic single-stage thermostat on two-stage equipment may keep it from delivering its full efficiency and comfort. Two-stage wiring typically needs extra conductors, so a professional should map the wires.

For very high-efficiency equipment, ENERGY STAR suggests considering a controller from the same manufacturer. Some variable-speed systems rely on a manufacturer-specific control, so ask the installer before replacing it.

Wiring and power

  • Most smart thermostats need continuous low-voltage power. Many need a C-wire (common wire). If your home lacks one, an adapter or new wire may be needed.
  • Google's compatibility page lists systems that are not supported, including high-voltage (120 V or 240 V) and millivolt systems. Other makers have their own lists.
  • The thermostat should sit on an interior wall away from direct sun, drafts, doors and windows, per the Maryland Energy Administration, or it will misread the room.

Questions people ask

Will a smart thermostat lower my bill?

It can, but the amount depends on your habits, equipment and placement. The Maryland Energy Administration describes savings of up to about 10 percent a year from setting back 7 to 10 degrees F for eight hours a day, and labels that a maximum, not a guarantee. Humid-climate setbacks need more caution, as above.

Is ENERGY STAR certification required?

No. It is a way to find models that were tested on field data. The criteria page ENERGY STAR links to carries a January 1, 2017 effective date, so confirm current criteria if that matters to you.

Can I install one myself?

Many homeowners do, but wiring a heat pump, a two-stage system or dual-fuel system is easier to get wrong. Mistakes can damage equipment. Thermostat replacement is a low-voltage task, yet if you are unsure about the labels on your wires, ask a licensed HVAC contractor. For permit and licensing rules on equipment changes, see AC permits and licensing in Miami-Dade.

Check before you decide

  1. Identify your equipment: single-speed, two-stage, variable-speed or heat pump, from the model labels.
  2. Use the thermostat maker's online compatibility checker with your wire terminal labels.
  3. Confirm whether you have a C-wire.
  4. Keep the fan on Auto unless a technician has a reason to change it.
  5. Use modest setbacks and monitor indoor humidity.
  6. Ask your installer whether your outdoor and indoor units need a manufacturer-specific control.

Product features and certification criteria change. Confirm details with the manufacturer and a licensed contractor before purchase.

Sources

  1. ENERGY STAR: Smart Thermostats
  2. Maryland Energy Administration: Smart Thermostats
  3. Carrier: What Is a Heat Pump Thermostat?
  4. Carrier: 2-Stage Thermostats, How They Work, Benefits and Compatibility
  5. Google Nest Help: Nest thermostat compatibility
  6. PNNL Building America Solution Center: Air Conditioning
  7. U.S. DOE: Humidity Control in Hot-Humid Climates (stakeholder slides, 2012)

Planning a project?

Tell AV Construction Group Corp. about your project and we will follow up.

Keep reading

More guides on the blog